In the second game of the doubleheader, Vassar fell to Brown City 6-5 in extra innings. After taking another early lead in the first inning, the Vulcans were unable to hold off the Green Devils from coming back. With the game tied in the last inning, Vassar was unable to capitalize with bases loaded. Brown City took their defensive momentum from stopping Vassar into the top of the seventh and scored the game-deciding run.
Max Kukulski took the loss for the Vulcans on the mound despite pitching well, only giving up one earned run and three hits in four innings pitched. Ricardo Macon had two RBIs on one hit and Noah Weisenberger had one hit and two runs scored in the game. Three other Vulcans tallied one hit in the game.